DIY vs Kitchen Company vs Architect and Builder: Which Approach is Best for your next Kitchen Renovation?

Designing and installing a new kitchen can be tackled in different ways, each with distinct price points, challenges, and outcomes. Here’s a clear breakdown of when to opt for DIY, a kitchen company, or an architect and builder, based on the scope and complexity of your project.

1. DIY (Flat-Pack Kitchens Like IKEA or Bunnings)

Best for: Budget-conscious, hands-on individuals with straightforward spaces.

When DIY Works:

• You’re handy with tools and confident about assembling and planning your kitchen—or looking for a new challenge. 🙂

• The layout fits standard-sized cabinetry, such as a single-wall kitchen or an open-ended layout.

• Tools like IKEA’s planning system help you design and order the right components.

• You’re prepared to put in the time to ensure the order is accurate and components fit correctly.

What to Watch For:

• Assembling and installing takes substantial time—especially if you’re not experienced with tools.

• Your walls may not be square and level. A common trap is getting everything in place only to realise your kitchen is square and plumb, but the room is not (which happens in both old and new properties).

• Ensuring drawers and doors open correctly without interfering with each other requires precise planning.

• Customisation (e.g., fitting cabinetry between two walls or adjusting for non-square spaces) quickly makes DIY less cost-effective and more frustrating.

Summary: DIY is a good option if your space suits off-the-shelf products and you have the time, skills, and patience. Avoid DIY if your kitchen needs heavy customisation or precise alignment with surrounding features.

2. Kitchen Companies

Best for: Simple, straightforward kitchen installations or replacements.

When to Use a Kitchen Company:

• The project is relatively simple, with no significant construction or design challenges.

• You’re not planning to move plumbing, windows, or walls.

• You know what you want, and the kitchen is largely a straight replacement without requiring approvals or submissions.

What Kitchen Companies Typically Handle:

• Designing your kitchen layout and advising on the best options for your space.

• Coordinating their own electrician and plumber for basic fit-offs, such as connecting appliances or minor electrical adjustments.

• Supplying and installing cabinets and benchtops with minimal hassle.

What to Watch For:

• If your project involves more than just the kitchen (e.g., adjacent structural or design work), a kitchen company may not have the capacity to manage those complexities.

• Kitchen companies specialise in kitchens, but they may not ensure alignment with adjacent windows, walls, or other features—especially if the space isn’t perfectly square. A good builder will make allowances for this.

Summary: Choose a kitchen company for straightforward projects without major structural changes or extensive adjacent work. They’re ideal for efficiently delivering a well-designed and installed kitchen when the scope is clear and simple.

3. Architect and Builder

Best for: Complex renovations or kitchens as part of a broader home redesign.

When You Need an Architect and Builder:

• The kitchen is part of a larger renovation project, such as moving walls or adding extensions.

• You’re unsure if the current kitchen layout is optimal and want professional input.

• The kitchen is the first stage of a multi-phase renovation, and it’s crucial to ensure it aligns with future plans.

• The design involves challenges, like limited space, unusual layouts, or other constraints.

• Structural changes (e.g., beams, relocating doors or windows) are required.

What Architects and Builders Offer:

• Architects solve design problems, ensuring your kitchen integrates with adjacent elements like windows, walls, and other features.

• They coordinate with engineers for structural work, handle approvals, and create solutions tailored to your home.

• Builders manage installation and coordinate trades, ensuring cabinetry, benchtops, and structural work align perfectly.

What to Watch For:

• This approach is more expensive upfront but ensures better long-term outcomes.

• Having a single designer for all elements ensures that everything—from walls to cabinetry—works together without costly mistakes or misalignment.

Summary: Opt for an architect and builder if your project involves structural changes, design challenges, or is part of a broader renovation. This ensures a cohesive result that integrates all aspects of your home.

Key Takeaways

• DIY: Great for budget-friendly projects with standard layouts but not ideal for complex spaces or customisation.

• Kitchen Company: Perfect for simple installations or replacements of standalone kitchens.

• Architect and Builder: Necessary for larger renovations, complex layouts, or projects involving structural changes.

Choose the approach that fits your needs, skills, and project scope. The right choice saves time, money, and stress in the long run.

Still unsure which option suits your project best? We’re happy to help. Get in touch to chat about your kitchen plans!